From Cells to Societies: A Dynamic Fractal
Dr. Robert Melamede, Ph.D. email@example.com
Phoenix Tears Foundation, Denver CO, USA; CannaHealth Labs, Colorado Springs CO;
Second Chance, Ecuador; CannaSapiens, Belgrade Serbia; Nostic Cannabis Cluster,
What if the standard random mutation-based view of the evolution of species and cancers is incomplete to the extent that it is an all-encompassing framework that misses a much bigger picture, the fundamental creative nature of nature. What if a reality of ongoing creation (GOD, General Open-System Dynamics) has been replaced with a stagnant dogma of accident driven evolution. If we reverse our current perspective, previously miraculous, improbable events may be scientifically understood from first principles that emerge by embracing a far from equilibrium thermodynamic perspective based on the work of Nobel laureate Ilya Prigogine.
Man’s understandings naturally start from the simple and move over time to the more complex. But, what is simple, what is complex, what is time, how and why is there change? An integration of physics and biology emerges after considering these terms from the perspective of far from equilibrium thermodynamics as developed by Nobel laureate Ilya Prigogine. The life’s work of Nobel laureate Ilya Prigogine provides an alternative foundation for understanding physics and life. In his last book, The End of Certainty, 1 he fully embraces his earlier work (From Being to Becoming 2) and concludes that flowing energy has a creative organizing capacity that is fully consistent with the Second Law of Thermodynamics (as extended by Prigogine for open systems). His perspective can now be extended to living systems, creating the “Physics of Life”,3 the physical basis for a systems biology perspective.
It is a well-established paradigm that the genetic transfer of information occurs through the transcription of DNA to RNA,4 followed by the translation of RNA into proteins which then integrate into life’s concert of homeostatically regulated enzymatic activities, post translational modifications playing a central role5.
The broadly accepted hypothesis in the scientific community is that life and evolution are the result of an accumulation of improbable accidental events that have miraculously been retained by evolution. This line of thinking is a natural consequence of foundational physics based on a logical mathematical formalism of timeless equilibrium. A logical extension of this perspective leads to the conclusion that time is reversible.6 However from this perspective, the appearance of irreversibility occurs in a time-biased fashion, at every instant, for unknown reasons. Thus there is a discrepancy between these conclusions and the everyday experiences of living organisms. We are guided by of the arrow of time from birth till death. Random statistics cannot explain life since it is statistically too improbable to exist.
Prigogine’s work explains how flowing energy can naturally organize matter to create flow-dependent structures that are thermodynamically stabilized by sufficient entropy production. Evolving complexity from this seminal thought provides a physical foundation for the emergence of life and evolution, driven by the creative nature of nature. Creativity can be thought of as solutions emerging from systemic complexity that better degrade thermodynamic potential. They emerge when a far from equilibrium systems are pushed to a flow-dependent critical point, at which time the system might spontaneously undergo a far from equilibrium phase space change to a higher level of spatial and temporal organization (negative entropy), or it might collapse to a lower level of organization, flow dependent or not.
What is a fractal and what is a dynamic fractal? The difference between a beautiful picture and life is time and adaptation. The fractal mathematics developed by Benoit Mandelbrot 7 creates beautiful complex pictures. Their algorithms generate repeating patterns independent of magnification used. With each cycle an element of time is created. Each reiteration can be visualized as a beautiful, flowing, sequence in a repetitive loop.
Unlike the generation of consistent patterns, life constantly must adapt to the environment that is constantly changed by adapting life. Therefore, algorithms for survival must constantly change. Feedback loops can create time dependent homeostasis. A system (a collection of molecules) is timeless when at equilibrium because entropy (disorder) is at a maximum and free energy (the ability to do anything) is at a minimum. Hence, everything is fully random and void of useful information (negative entropy). There is no change to manifest time.1 In contrast, a network of localized inorganic, flow-dependent reactions, interacting, feeding and being fed by each other, can (must?) ultimately lead to the far from equilibrium phase change known as life.
Environmental conditions, from the sub-cellular to the planetary, create flow dependent
structures that are in turn affected by their own creation, thus creating an adaptable
dynamic fractal. Consequently, a complex landscape of evolving selective pressures
maintains ongoing homeostatic ability with constant dynamic adaptability. Evolution of
all complex systems, across scales of time and space, are driven by the flow of excess
energy potential and the production of entropy.8 The flow of living systems is maintained
by building complexity in concert with appropriate cellular damage prevention (antioxidant) and recycling (autophagy) efforts. The energy flux of these processes are in
constant dynamic free radical guided self adjustment to overcome the friction of life,
excess free radicals i.e. entropy. Life and evolution must occur because they are driven by
the flow of energy 9. The conclusions that emerge from the joining biology with far from
equilibrium thermodynamics shake the foundations of our universally accepted truths,
while providing direction for the future.
It appears that the scientific establishment has failed to grasp the genetic consequences of life’s most fundamental property, adaptability. Currently, the physical foundations of life are ironically embedded in a dead, equilibrium perspective of random statistics. However, the ability of flowing electrons to create statistically essentially impossible molecular distributions, such as those seen in Belousov–Zhabotinsky reaction, 10 suggests a clear parallel with the metabolic redox processes of living systems. Redox reactions can account for
emergence and evolution of life, as well as all manifestations of human consciousness and all of our societal structures (financial, political, religious, educational, etc.).11 Thus, a more advanced perspective of humanity’s place in the chemistry set of evolution needs to be developed and implemented for natural harmony. A new level of human consciousness must emerge to successfully integrate with the environment to become part of the future.
Flowing energy, in order to maintain the high level of adaptability characteristic of living systems, for now best exemplified by human beings, requires sophisticated feedback mechanisms in order to monitor the balance between negative entropy accumulation and entropy production. Human consciousness is the mechanism, but it needs a scientific foundation for guidance. Entropy exported by a flow-dependent system must be greater than the negative entropy retained in order to have thermodynamic stability. dST(total)/dt=dSE(exchange)/dt+dSI(internal)/dt Is there a common characteristic that can be monitored in order for the system achieve and remain stable? If so, what is its nature, and what are the biological manifestations by which homeostatic adaptability is accomplished?
The answer to these questions will integrate free radical-induced biochemical changes (homeostatic and/or damaging excess) with the intrinsic truth that in a human population everything is regulated by endocannabinoid activity12 from conception to death. By definition, half the people will be above and half will be below average for any particular phenotype, for example forgetfulness, chosen because memory is intrinsically required for the required feedback necessary for homeostasis. How might forgetfulness be involved with evolutionary adaptability? Clearly, from the perspective of adaptation, there should be an advantage when incorrect information is replaced with updated new
and presumably more correct information. The nature of all flow dependent structures will always reflect the sources that created, and feed them. Consequently, the harmony of exchanges between these structures with their environment must constantly adapt as the environment adapts to nature’s ever unfolding creativity. The consequences in a population that results from a distribution of cannabinoid effects on memory will be reflected in the flow dependent structures (dissipative structures13) that constitute ourselves and those that we create as complexity increases. Increasing complexity actually creates time, be it in cells or society.
Memory is intrinsically a fundamental asset to living systems because allows for responsive non-random behavior. As the complexity of organisms increases, the consequences of memory permeate the organism’s negentropic hierarchy. Superficially, it may seem that a greater memory capacity would naturally be beneficial. However, with the complexities of human consciousness, forgetting has become essential for optimizing adaptability. A functional role for forgetting in the learning process is suggested in mice where low cannabinoid activity appears to interfere with the retention of non reinforced learning.14 Extrapolating the animal behavioral studies to people, those with lower levels of cannabinoid activity (both endogenous and consumed) will typically experience greater levels of stress because of their lower ability to sufficiently control free radical damage production that results from/in change. Psychologically and physiologically they are less likely to forget stresses from the past.
Cannabinoids protectively regulate damage-causing free radical generation by balancing dangerous carbohydrate promoted ATP production, produced by electron transport system for differentiated cellular functions, with protective recycling activity promoted when cells burn fats and recycle free radical damage components. A destructive phenotype emerges as positive feedback loop. These individuals may suffer from an inability to deal with current stress due to lower endocannabinoid activities. Stress permeates and regulates the flow-dependent complexities of life by the free radical induced changes in biological molecules that control critical flow patterns. Consequently, environmentally determined epigenetic changes institutionalize behavior. As will be explained below, the main theme of this manuscript is that life successfully transformations metabolic patterns into epigenetic patterns that increase the probability of creating supporting genetics.
Vertebrates with above average levels of cannabinoid activity for any phenotype under consideration will have different characteristics than those with lower levels. Profoundly, CB1 knockout mice that lack CB1 activity and cannot get “high,” die prematurely, and are too stressed to move about their cage 15. Without sufficient cannabinoid activity, stressful memories are more effectively retained. A deficiency in forgetting results in an individual spending more conscious time looking backwards (remembering) because the past represents a known, even if unpleasant. The past is safe because nothing is new so no adaptation is required. Some individuals with strong memories coupled with a fearful predisposition may represent individuals deficient in cannabinoid activity (BLPs = Backward Looking People). There are additional phenotypes that have been demonstrated in CB1 deficient
The more stressed an individual is, the greater the tendency to try to control the future
stress from forgotten and unforgotten stresses of the past. In contrast, Forward Looking
People (FLPs) may have a greater tendency to embrace the unknown because they are
more optimistic and tend to be more relaxed because they more readily forget the stresses
of the past. The optimistic FLP may be predisposed to taking more chances that a
pessimistic BLP. Consequently, they may naturally be more accident-prone. Individuals
with this phenotype are more likely to experiment with the unknown and maybe even
dare to try cannabis. This simple possibility invalidates many epidemiological studies that
assume a random distribution of whatever characteristic is being examined. These studies
assume that there is an equal probability of cannabis use among sick versus healthy
individuals, between those suffering pain and those not suffering pain, how foolish. It has
already becoming quite clear that people with chronic conditions prefer to use cannabisbased
treatments rather than more conventional pharmaceutical alternatives.17
Stress, and its avoidance, is a determinant of behavior, it’s important to have a realistic
definition of “stress.” Thermodynamically stress may be viewed as any change to which
a flow dependent homeostatic system must adapt, good or bad, for systemic survival.
Homeostasis always requires continuous adjustments of flow. As within each individual,
in a dynamic fractal-like manner, the collective consciousness of a population is
intrinsically regulated by the balance between BLP and FLP activities. Relaxation is a
multidimensional biological process facilitated by cannabinoids because of their
ubiquitous homeostatic ability to regulate free radical activity. Cannabinoids are
adaptogens.18 Without sufficient cannabinoid activity a person is naturally tend to look
more fearful19 of the unknowns intrinsic in the future. They are driven to control the
future by staying in the past. Their conservative nature emerges and provides a biological
and philosophical rationale for becoming a political and religious aggregate of likeminded
thinkers that provide social stability.
However, social stability must be balanced with progress since everything is always
changing as the future unfolds. How to best optimize for a successful future?20 A natural
starting point would be to understand the nature of our creation so that we can become
more harmonious and synergistic with it. Understanding the physics and biological
manifestations of flowing energy seems to be logically mandated. With sufficient flow
and evolving complexity, nonlinear rearrangements will occur as they always have in the
past. From the perspective of the evolving human mind, what might we expect? The
physical foundations of evolving biological systems will echo throughout a dynamic
system’s evolving complexity. Social systems,21 including education, politics, finances and international interactions will spontaneously reorganize as the human brain evolves
concurrently, as it always has, with increase cannabinoid activity. Canna sapiens will
emerge from Homo sapiens, as a higher (more cannabinoid activity), less self-destructive
How might the integration of far from equilibrium thermodynamic thinking affect our
understanding of life and evolution? It is a well-established paradigm that the genetic
transfer of information occurs from DNA to RNA, its subsequent translation into proteins
integrate into life’s concert of homeostatically regulated enzymatic activities. A broadly
accepted thought in the scientific community is that life and evolution are the result of an
accumulation of improbable accidental events miraculously retained by evolution. This
line thinking is a natural consequence of foundational physics that is based on a logical
mathematical formalism of timeless equilibrium (maximum entropy, minimum free
energy). A logical extension naturally leads to the conclusion time that is reversible.
Essentially, the appearance of irreversibility in our everyday world20 occurs in a timebiased
fashion at any instant for unknown reasons. There is a discrepancy between these
conclusions and the everyday experiences of living organisms that are guided by of the
arrow of time. Random, time independent statistics cannot explain life. It is too
improbable to exist.
Before new biological concepts can be examined, the physical underpinnings of life must
be considered. Prigogine provides a novel foundation that can be developed into a
synergistic understanding of physics and life. Surprisingly, it appears that the scientific
establishment has missed understanding the genetic consequences of life’s most
fundamental property, adaptability. Currently, the physical foundations of life are
ironically embedded in a dead, equilibrium perspective of random statistics. The ability
of flowing electrons to create a statistically impossible molecular distribution, as seen in
the Belousov–Zhabotinsky reaction, 10 provides a clear parallel with the metabolic redox
processes of living systems.
Life and evolution are driven by the creative nature of nature. Creativity, solutions of
systemic complexity that degrade potential, emerge when far from equilibrium systems
are pushed to a flow dependent critical point whereby the system spontaneously
undergoes a far from equilibrium phase change to a higher level of spatiotemporal
organization (negative entropy). Conceptually, a network of localized, inorganic flow
dependent reactions interacting, feeding and being fed by each other, ultimately move a
system a sufficient distance from equilibrium and the far from equilibrium phase change
of life emerges and is repeated throughout the evolution of species.
All Environmental conditions, both sub-cellular and planetary, create flow dependent
structures that are in turn will be affected by systemic interactions resulting from their
own creation thus creating a dynamic fractal. Consequently, a complex landscape of
evolving, selective pressures maintains ongoing homeostatic ability with constant
dynamic adaptability. Evolution of all systems, across scales of time and space, are driven by excess energy potential but that is maintained by appropriate cellular prevention
(antioxidant) and recycling (autophagy) efforts that are in constant engagement to
overcome the consequences of the friction of life, free radicals. Life and evolution must
occur, driven by the flow of energy, but shaped by free radicals. Consequently, below is a
metabolic perspective on the evolution of species and cancers. Life’s main energy
sources, carbohydrates and lipids, are not functionally equivalent.22,23 Carbohydrates
preferentially feed the efficient, but dangerous, electron transport system that promotes
and supports differentiated cellular functions including nerve transmission, muscle
contraction, and hormone production. Essentially, efficient energy production promoted
by metabolizing carbohydrates through the electron transport system is the functional
equivalent of a nuclear reactor that sometimes leaks radioactivity in a cell. Electron
transport system in mitochondria provides efficient, clean energy in the form of ATP to
drive cellular differentiation. But, imbalances can produce excess free radicals. A
complex society in all of its manifestations can be built with sufficient energy
availability. Similarly, so can the differentiated functions of cells can be performed.
Unfortunately mitochondrial energy producing metabolism, like radiation represents the,
produces free radicals under conditions of inappropriate mitochondrial input 24, or
restricted outflow. When excess free radicals are metabolically produced, cells will
produce fat, through well-established pathways that range from whole body to
subcellular, in order to reduce excess free radical production from excess carbohydrate
catabolism. From an entropic perspective, both the intracellular and social recycling
enhances negentropic activity. Their dialogue allows a state of health to emerge from
living systems and their societies, mathematically known as an attractor.
A novel concept that emerges from the thermodynamic
perspective is that the there is an optimal state of health for each organism that can be represented as an attractor. In most humans, it is suggested that the health attractor is likely to represent the transition from youth to adulthood. Quite astonishingly, it seems that when a cell, or organism, sufficiently recycle free radical damaged cellular components (autophagy), the biochemistry moves towards that attractor, and thus helps to restore health.
In vertebrates, CB1/electron transport driven ATP production, and subsequent production of cellular biochemical and free radicals, is balanced by recycling free radical damaged cellular components driven by CB2 activity. Less electron transport driven energy and
associated free radical production occurs when cells recycle. Additionally, since fat
burning is promoted by CB2 activity,25 it may also promote beta-oxidation dependent
symmetrical stem cell expansion as occurs in embryonic stem cells.26 In contrast, CB1
activity promotes electron transport system driven stem cell differentiation.27 From
metabolic perspective, a more differentiated cell is driven further from equilibrium
because it is more negentropic than a less differentiated one. Functionally, different circuits of metabolic pathways may expand or contract to modulate free radical induced
damage production that occurs with electron transport activity. The prominent role of
aerobic glycolysis and glutaminolysis are examples of energy-production-efficiency
plasticity used as a buffering mechanism to homeostatically maintain safe steady states of
free radical production that can be efficiently handled by steady-state levels of enzymes
that reduce the negative consequences of excess free radicals.
Metabolic parameters describe common functional cellular states in healthy and cancer
cells, the difference being their regulation. A senescent embryonic stem cell, like the
initial zygote, is totipotent and has minimal energy requirements. It stably survives with
minimal free radical induced perturbations by using fat as the dominant fuel source.
Environmental factors can trigger either symmetrical cell division that produces two
totipotent fat burning stem cells, or asymmetrical division that produces another stem cell
(totipotent?) as well as one differentiated cell that has turned on the electron transport
system to form the metabolic basis for further differentiation28. Effectively these cells
became adult stem cells prior to achieving their final differentiated state. They have not
made the epithelial-mesenchymal transition to a higher level of differentiation. For
example, these cells have not developed anchorage dependent differentiation functions.
They may remain detached and mobile until a nourishing home is found that provides
them with the needed developmental signals to settle down and start a colony that may be
part of healthy growth and/or restoration, or it may be a sugar fueled cancer metastasis. In
either case, a spectrum energy patterns fuel survival.
Free radicals drive progressive selection of survivable metabolic states in cells, a process
that leads to the development of cancers. Cannabis as well as other herbal/nutritional
options can promote the killing of these cells by forcing them to burn fat. AMPK
activation controls the transition to fat burning. Is responsible for turning off the electron
transport system and inhibiting the alternative safe energy source, the Warburg affect, aka
aerobic glycolysis 29–31. Healthy cells can successfully make this metabolic transition.
However cancer cells already producing excess free radicals and typically cannot
successfully make the transition. They undergo apoptosis from the excess free radical
Unfortunately continued exposure to therapy induced excess free radical production in cancer cells can select for more survivable metabolic states that subsequently create their required genetic changes for long-term survival. A lethal feedback loop can amplify the metabolic/genetic catastrophe to produce more stable, death resistant, less differentiated, fat burning cancer cells. The disease worsens as the imbalance is amplified by free radical inducing treatments. The worst-case scenario seems to be coupling the protective properties of fat burning with the enhanced flow required to sustain cell division. This type of cancer cell actually grows when treated, for example with radiation. The man’s head in the picture below show the tumors that would grow when treated. He was irradiated over 100 times! Healthcare or Wealthcare?
These treatment resistant tumors still responded to cannabis extracts (topical and oral
consumption) . Al l other treatments had failed to stop tumor growth. The images below show that otherwise drug and radiation resistant tumors were progressively destroyed,
down to the bone, by what appeared to be a necrotic process.
Patients have used excess free radicals to kill drug resistant cells using metabolic
manipulation to reduce normal metabolic escape pathways, coupled with additional free radical overload with high dose intravenous vitamin C (interacts with iron in the blood to produce hydroxyl radicals, the Fenton reaction). For any cell, metabolic status will determine whether free radical stress will induce apoptotic or necrotic death. Plasticity of energy flow in vertebrate systems is emphasized by the presence of the CB1 receptor on mitochondria 32 and components of the electron transport system on the plasma membrane of human cells 33. In essence, we as a species are exploring the possibly that the source of human regenerative capacity is implemented through the endocannabinoid system, possibly with significant neurological stimulation and guidance. We are just beginning the journey out of ignorance as the will Global Cannabis Awakening proceeds.
The main concept developed in this chapter is that survival of the fittest means survival
of the most adaptable, not the strongest and not the smartest. Consequently, adaptability
of a flow dependent system mandates that the constant adaptive interface between the
system and its environment occur at the metabolic, not the genetic level. Metabolic
imbalances promote excess free radical production that create epigenetic modifications,
followed by focused genetic change on the genes and their controlling regions that are
responsible for thermodynamic flow dependent survival. DNA damage and its repair
provide a source of the changes that characterize evolution34 (gene duplications,
recombinational events, low fidelity error prone DNA polymerases that bypass damages
stalled replication and transcription forks35, replication/transcription conflicts27, retroviral
activation, etc. Consequently it seems that there are two pathways by which evolution
advances, one random, and the other nonrandom. Directed change occurs by
metabolically selecting/directing needed, nonrandom, free radical–promoted genetic
change, by selecting metabolic states in a multi-gene fashion that promotes a systemic
metabolic survival state. Metabolically directed is quasi-Lamarckian molecular evolution.
Statistically, the above perspective makes intrinsic sense. DNA is a complex molecule unlikely to randomly form from its components. How is it that DNA is probably the most successful molecule in the universe? An estimated 50,000,000,000 tons exists on the planet Earth.36 The answer found in the success of molecular cooperation driven by flowing energy and entropy production. Energy driving evolutionary change provides an easy to understand explanation for the evolution of life, species and similarly, cancer drug resistance and the genetic diversity of tumors. Potential important beneficial health consequences, especially with respect to cancer need to be considered. The existing scientific/medical framework has been unsuccessful in creating the desired health
outcomes. Yet, a simple shift in perspective creates an entirely new reality when considering the causes and treatments of cancers.
The far from equilibrium approach to understanding life intrinsically leads to the all
pervasive role of flowing energy in creating and sustaining life. Numerous reports
coming from varying biological specialties are increasingly finding metabolic solutions
for health concerns. An extreme example demonstrates the utility of a cannabis-driven
metabolic approach. Multiple cancers result from genetic defects in a cell’s ability to
repair ultraviolet light induced mutagenic DNA damages. The patient below shows a
multi-phenotypic reversal, in I year, by cannabis extracts of the genetic deficiency
Xeroderma pigmentosum37) that cause cancers. The cannabis-based treatment protocol
eliminated pain and depression, while healing melanoma on the scalp, as well as tongue
and lip cancers. Additionally, sight was restored (personal communication B. Radisic, J.
Is there a connection between the lack of nucleotide excision repair seen in Xeroderma
pigmentosum and the potential for cannabinoids to regulate free radical production and potentially associated base excision repair?38 It is important to remember that when we are dealing with open systems we are focusing on dynamic not static processes.
Consequently small perturbations can be amplified into macroscopic systemic changes
(the well-known butterfly effect). The human body has approximately 15 trillion cells
that every day suffer at least 30,000 oxidative base damages.39 One damage, at one point in time and in the wrong gene could kill a person if it amplifies through the system to
create a lethal cancer. Common sense dictates that an extensive amount of life’s
organization must be devoted to protecting life from excess free radical damage and the
organizational disruption that free radicals impose on cellular biochemical harmony.
When flow dependent organization decreases below a thermodynamic critical point it
leads to the systemic negentropic collapse, commonly known as apoptosis.
One of the most dramatic examples of metabolic adaptability in response to potential free
radical damage is seen when a cell enters S-phase of the cell cycle. The electron transport
system, after having efficiently provided the needed energy to build up a cell’s
negentropic potential during anabolic production during the G1 phase of the cell cycle, is
shut down. The free radical modifications of cellular constituents become the
multidimensional signaling elements of homeostasis. They form the feedback loop that
directs cells to minimize the excess free radical production coming from the electron
transport system. By significantly increasing use of the safer, but less efficient aerobic
glycolysis process, a.k.a. the Warburg affect 40. Evolution selected for S-phase energy not
to be produced by the electron transport system when DNA is unwrapped and more
susceptible to damage. Instead, replicating cells get their energy from anaerobic
glycolysis and glutaminolysis41,42.
What might the consequences metabolic flexibility be from a dynamic perspective?
Imagine a population of cancer cells having a single mutation in the same gene. An
unsynchronized population will be in all phases of the cell cycle. Those that cannot
efficiently amplify free radical imbalances to cause apoptosis will survive any assault that
kills by an apoptotic mechanism. Consequently, cells in S-phase will have a greater
probability of surviving while simultaneously free radical induced damages and their
repair will be focused on replicating and transcribed genes. Abnormally prolonged
transcription of free radical stressed metabolic patterns will naturally select mutations
that promote successful metabolic flow that is defined by transcription and enzymatic
activity patterns. Thus, many cancers are characterized by increased energy flux through
aerobic glycolysis and glutaminolysis pathways. They were probably initially
nonrandomly metabolically selected for prior to becoming imbedded in genetics as a
consequence of metabolically focused genetic change. Functional directed genetic change
is a scientific version of creationism.
Similarly, glutaminolysis, driven by the MYC oncogene43 provides an additional ATP
source that maintains the carbohydrate driven differentiated state by supporting Krebs
cycle intermediates. In contrast, as with aerobic glycolysis,30 glutaminolysis44 and AMPK
activity seem mutually exclusive, again separating synthetic and differentiated pathways
from those responsible for recycling of free radical damage to cellular components. An
overview of metabolic options explains both the origins and treatment possibilities of
cancers, as well as all diseases. The use of chemotherapy and radiation45 simply selects
for the surviving metabolic states that subsequently become institutionalized as genetics.
Shut down of cellular communication with the outside, while focusing on internal
recycling. Autophagy moves the system to a lower level of communication with the
environment while decreasing its internal entropy by reducing free radical damage
associated molecular circuitry through recycling. Autophagy can become a cell’s ultimate
survival mechanism,46 which is good when the cell survives, re-differentiates and rejoins
the community of cells as a harmonious part of the greater structure. DNA is the record of
Adaptation requires that first a unique biochemical state is selected that is typically
maintained by epigenetics synergistically with the metabolic adaptation from homeostatic
post-translational modifications. Consequently, excess free radical damages, due to
maintaining and expanding an original metabolic imbalance, are focused on
transcriptionally active genes47 that promote survival. Consequently, the damages
themselves, the DNA nicks and single-stranded regions that are undergoing repair, can
promote recombinational events, gene duplications, and mutations, providing new
material for evolution.48 For example, stalled DNA and RNA polymerase molecules can
generate a variety of novel DNA outcomes.49, 50, 51 The significance of DNA architecture
is emphasized by the fact there exists both global DNA repair as well as transcriptioncoupled
repair.52,53 DNA repair systems operate in different environments, architecturally
and biochemically. A variety of consequences, depending on circumstantial specifics,
should be expected. For example DNA repair can trigger DNA strand breaks that trigger
polyADP-ribose polymerase hyper-activation (Parp) that links DNA repair with NAD
metabolism and necrotic cell death.54
The above proposal clearly challenges conventional modern interpretations of molecular genetics and its role in evolutionary change. The evolution of species, and cancers for the most part is not the randomly created mutations on a genome wide level, but focus of mutational change where it’s needed, the genes that are responsible for survival in any metabolic state. Add to that intellectual perturbation of corroborated, unpublished studies (personal communication YW Kow, Z Hatahet) that demonstrated the fat burning, drug/radiation resistant HL60 monocytic cells do not express base excision repair enzymes. In contrast, these repair enzymes were expressed in the drug sensitive parent cell line. (Melamede and Stubbs, unpublished results).
In conclusion, life is a natural endpoint after 1 billion years of energy driven chemical
complexity evolving in the test tube planet Earth. We now have sufficient scientific
foundation to understand the nature of that process so that human health and planetary health may be best addressed for healthy survival. Each individual living organism is simply a flow dependent, quantized probe in adaptability (not good for the ego), adapting as the complexity of the chemical reaction moves into the future. Embracing adaptability
facilitates movement into the future. Cannabinoid deficient BLPs currently run the
world, unfortunately too often, driven by greed and power, a natural consequence of a
more primitive state (no pun intended), naturally of FLPs, In contrast, the activist medical
cannabis community that is leading the Cannabis Awakening successfully uses cannabisbased
metabolic approaches (whether they know it or not) to control cancers, HIV and
associated illnesses, dementia, dyslipidemia, Kaposi sarcoma, autoimmune diseases, pain,
fibrotic illnesses etc. numerous age-related inflammatory based imbalances in body
The concepts are simple. A state of health can only be achieved with a balance of damage
production, with repair and prevention. For the first time we have a simple definition of
health, it can be measure by moving the system further from equilibrium in a sustainable
fashion. The complexity of an organism grows as it matures both by increasing the
amount of matter as well as increasing its organization (negative entropy 55). Aging and
age-related illnesses promote a return to equilibrium. Death is a far from equilibrium
phase change to a lower level of organization. It is encouraged to our ignorance. Once a
human reaches adulthood they no longer move further from equilibrium by growing in
size unless, for most people, they’re just getting fat. A fat body is further from
equilibrium. If burned, it would release more energy then a thinner body of equal weight.
In terms of health promoting complexity a fat, unfit human is closer to equilibrium. Fat is
simply an indication that the organism was consuming too many hydrates. In order to not
burn them and generate excess free radicals, the cells turn carbohydrates into fat. The
popular Ketogenic56 and Paleo57 diets promote cellular recycling, consistent with the
increasing appreciation the metabolic underpinnings of so many conditions. A thin person
is not necessarily metabolically healthy call they may suffer from a metabolic imbalance
where the body is excessively burning fat to compensate for the excess free radical
production, as would occur from inappropriate excess carbohydrate intake that leads to
The entire planet is now undergoing a far from equilibrium phase change characterized
by fluctuations of the intensive variables of the system that approach infinity. From a
physicochemical perspective, these are measurable parameters that occur prior to a far
from equilibrium phase change. Today we see supporting indications for this possibility
on the global level in the form of fluctuating weather patterns, novel migrations of
species including humans, inappropriate distributions of chemicals such as the plastic
poisoning the oceans, and the nanoparticles that we eat and breathe, etc. The energy and
associated information flow in the modern world is generating excess stress, and hence
increasing our free radical load. Our ignorance regarding the physics of life keeps us
supporting wealth-care instead healthcare.
Today “citizen scientists” all around the world are dramatically improving their health
with a variety of cannabis-based preparations that contain highly variable biologically
active landscapes. Typically people are treating themselves at home, often in the absence
of medical oversight. Metabolically, every human is different, even twins. In order to
most effectively use cannabis, each patient needs to develop a relationship based on self experimentation so they can match their medical needs with the medicinal properties that
different strains provide. As the godfather of cannabis, Dr. Mechoulam has stated,
“cannabis is a treasure trove of pharmacologically active chemicals”. 58 Globally,
cannabis activists are educating and people are successfully treating themselves for
illnesses and conditions for which the healthcare system failed to provide any satisfying
real health-promoting solutions. Autism promoted by vaccines, cancers metabolic
syndrome and autoimmune diseases are all promoted by a toxic environment, toxic food
and bad information promoted by healthcare, and society in general. They are
recognizing fake medicine and fake science. They are demanding cannabis freedom for
survival. Along with that freedom will come new concepts whose implementation will
drive health and the genetics.
As more and more people recognize the harm that ignorant, corrupt, (collusion with the
biomedical industry) governments are causing the people they are supposed to be
helping, Only those that adapt and support a healthier, happier future for people and the
planet will remain. The future will be one no longer of power, but of cooperation if we
are to survive. Consequently, the increased cannabinoid activity in the human population
will become embedded ultimately in the genetics that will stabilize, at least temporarily,
until new adaptation is implemented.
Life is an adaptive negentropic flow dependent superconductor driven by the adaptive
coherent flow of the adaptive redox potential that collaborate to manifest as time,
distance from equilibrium, as complexity emerges. Life is a dynamic redox capacitor that stores evolving negentropic complexity.
I would like to thank Dr. Susan Wallace for putting up with me for so many years, the late Dr. Ilya Prigogine for guiding my life, Dr. Raphael Mechoulam for providing so much of my foundation in cannabis science, and Dr. Matt Hogg for editing all the parts that make sense and are grammatically correct.
1. Prigogine, I. The End of Certainty (Free Press, 1997).
2. Prigogine, I. From Being to Becoming: Time and Complexity in the Physical
Sciences (W H Freeman & Co (Sd), 1981).
3. Melamede, R. J. Dissipative Structures and the Origins of Life. Interjournal
Complex Systems 601 (2006).
4. Krebs, J. E., Goldstein, E. S. & Kilpatrick, S. T. Lewin’s GENES XII. (2017).
5. Santos, A. L. & Lindner, A. B. Protein Posttranslational Modifications: Roles in
Aging and Age-Related Disease. Oxid Med Cell Longev 2017, 5716409 (2017).
6. Highfield, R. & Coveney, P. The Arrow Of Time. (2015).
7. Mandelbrot, B. How long is the coast of britain? Statistical self-similarity and
fractional dimension. Science 156, 636-638 (1967).
8. Kleidon, A. Nonequilibrium thermodynamics and maximum entropy production in
the Earth system: applications and implications. Naturwissenschaften 96, 653-677
9. I, P. & r, L. Symmetry Breaking Instabilities in Dissipative Systems II. (1968).
10. Pechenkin, A. B P Belousov and his reaction. J Biosci 34, 365-371 (2009).
11. Melamede, R. J. Endocannabinoids: Multi-scaled, Global Homeostatic Regulators
of Cells and Society. Interjournal Complex Systems 1669 (2006).
12. Maccarrone, M. et al. Endocannabinoid signaling at the periphery: 50 years after
THC. Trends Pharmacol Sci 36, 277-296 (2015).
13. Goldbeter, A. & Lefever, R. Dissipative structures for an allosteric model.
Application to glycolytic oscillations. Biophys J 12, 1302-1315 (1972).
14. Varvel, S. A., Anum, E. A. & Lichtman, A. H. Disruption of CB(1) receptor
signaling impairs extinction of spatial memory in mice. Psychopharmacology (Berl)
15. Zimmer, A., Zimmer, A. M., Hohmann, A. G., Herkenham, M. & Bonner, T. I.
Increased mortality, hypoactivity, and hypoalgesia in cannabinoid CB1 receptor
knockout mice. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 96, 5780-5785 (1999).
16. Varvel, S. A. & Lichtman, A. H. Evaluation of CB1 receptor knockout mice in the
Morris water maze. J Pharmacol Exp Ther 301, 915-924 (2002).
17. Bruce, D., Brady, J. P., Foster, E. & Shattell, M. Preferences for Medical Marijuana
over Prescription Medications Among Persons Living with Chronic Conditions:
Alternative, Complementary, and Tapering Uses. J Altern Complement Med 24,
18. Kaur, P. et al. Immunopotentiating significance of conventionally used plant
adaptogens as modulators in biochemical and molecular signalling pathways in cell
mediated processes. Biomed Pharmacother 95, 1815-1829 (2017).
19. Segev, A. et al. Role of endocannabinoids in the hippocampus and amygdala in
emotional memory and plasticity. Neuropsychopharmacology 43, 2017-2027
20. Prigogine, I. Is Future Given? (World Scientific Publishing Company, 2003).
21. Wascher, C. A. F., Kulahci, I. G., Langley, E. J. G. & Shaw, R. C. How does
cognition shape social relationships. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 373,
22. Harper, M. E. et al. Characterization of a novel metabolic strategy used by drugresistant
tumor cells. FASEB J 16, 1550-1557 (2002).
23. Newell, M. K. et al. The effects of chemotherapeutics on cellular metabolism and
consequent immune recognition. J Immune Based Ther Vaccines 2, 3 (2004).
24. Dubouchaud, H., Walter, L., Rigoulet, M. & Batandier, C. Mitochondrial NADH
redox potential impacts the reactive oxygen species production of reverse Electron
transfer through complex I. J Bioenerg Biomembr (2018).
25. Morell, C. et al. The cannabinoid WIN 55,212-2 prevents neuroendocrine
differentiation of LNCaP prostate cancer cells. Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis 19,
26. Xie, Z., Jones, A., Deeney, J. T., Hur, S. K. & Bankaitis, V. A. Inborn Errors of
Long-Chain Fatty Acid β-Oxidation Link Neural Stem Cell Self-Renewal to
Autism. Cell Rep 14, 991-999 (2016).
27. Molina-Holgado, E. et al. Cannabinoids promote oligodendrocyte progenitor
survival: involvement of cannabinoid receptors and phosphatidylinositol-3 kinase/
Akt signaling. J Neurosci 22, 9742-9753 (2002).
28. Gonzalez, M. J. et al. The bio-energetic theory of carcinogenesis. Med Hypotheses
79, 433-439 (2012).
29. Kishton, R. J. et al. AMPK Is Essential to Balance Glycolysis and Mitochondrial
Metabolism to Control T-ALL Cell Stress and Survival. Cell Metab 23, 649-662
30. Liu, Y. et al. Resveratrol inhibits the proliferation and induces the apoptosis in
ovarian cancer cells via inhibiting glycolysis and targeting AMPK/mTOR signaling
pathway. J Cell Biochem 119, 6162-6172 (2018).
31. Lian, N. et al. Curcumin inhibits aerobic glycolysis in hepatic stellate cells
associated with activation of adenosine monophosphate-activated protein kinase.
IUBMB Life 68, 589-596 (2016).
32. Hebert-Chatelain, E. et al. Cannabinoid control of brain bioenergetics: Exploring
the subcellular localization of the CB1 receptor. Mol Metab 3, 495-504 (2014).
33. Lee, H. et al. Extracellular reactive oxygen species are generated by a plasma
membrane oxidative phosphorylation system. Free Radic Biol Med 112, 504-514
34. Fakouri, N. B. et al. Rev1 contributes to proper mitochondrial function via the
PARP-NAD+-SIRT1-PGC1α axis. Sci Rep 7, 12480 (2017).
35. Almeida, R. et al. Chromatin conformation regulates the coordination between
DNA replication and transcription. Nat Commun 9, 1590 (2018).
36. Zhang, Y. et al. Lysine desuccinylase SIRT5 binds to cardiolipin and regulates the
electron transport chain. J Biol Chem 292, 10239-10249 (2017).
37. de Jager, T. L., Cockrell, A. E. & Du Plessis, S. S. Ultraviolet Light Induced
Generation of Reactive Oxygen Species. Adv Exp Med Biol 996, 15-23 (2017).
38. Melis, J. P., van Steeg, H. & Luijten, M. Oxidative DNA damage and nucleotide
excision repair. Antioxid Redox Signal 18, 2409-2419 (2013).
39. Bernstein, C., Nfonsam, V., Prasad, A. R. & Bernstein, H. Epigenetic field defects
in progression to cancer. World J Gastrointest Oncol 5, 43-49 (2013).
40. Warburg, O. THE CHEMICAL CONSTITUTION OF RESPIRATION FERMENT.
Science 68, 437-443 (1928).
41. Estevez-Garcia, I. O. et al. Glucose and glutamine metabolism control by APC and
SCF during the G1-to-S phase transition of the cell cycle. J Physiol Biochem
42. Bao, Y. et al. Energy management by enhanced glycolysis in G1-phase in human
colon cancer cells in vitro and in vivo. Mol Cancer Res 11, 973-985 (2013).
43. Qu, X. et al. c-Myc-driven glycolysis via TXNIP suppression is dependent on
glutaminase-MondoA axis in prostate cancer. Biochem Biophys Res Commun
44. Sato, M. et al. Low uptake of fluorodeoxyglucose in positron emission tomography/
computed tomography in ovarian clear cell carcinoma may reflect glutaminolysis of
its cancer stem cell-like properties. Oncol Rep 37, 1883-1888 (2017).
45. Zhong, J. et al. Radiation induces aerobic glycolysis through reactive oxygen
species. Radiother Oncol (2013).
46. Steelman, L. S. et al. Involvement of Akt and mTOR in chemotherapeutic- and
hormonal-based drug resistance and response to radiation in breast cancer cells.
Cell Cycle 10, 3003-3015 (2011).
47. Owiti, N., Lopez, C., Singh, S., Stephenson, A. & Kim, N. Def1 and Dst1 play
distinct roles in repair of AP lesions in highly transcribed genomic regions. DNA
Repair (Amst) 55, 31-39 (2017).
48. Watanabe, T. et al. Impediment of Replication Forks by Long Non-coding RNA
Provokes Chromosomal Rearrangements by Error-Prone Restart. Cell Rep 21,
49. Pipathsouk, A., Belotserkovskii, B. P. & Hanawalt, P. C. When transcription goes on
Holliday: Double Holliday junctions block RNA polymerase II transcription in
vitro. Biochim Biophys Acta 1860, 282-288 (2017).
50. Huang, M. et al. RNA-splicing factor SART3 regulates translesion DNA synthesis.
Nucleic Acids Res 46, 4560-4574 (2018).
51. Gerhardt, J. et al. Stalled DNA Replication Forks at the Endogenous GAA Repeats
Drive Repeat Expansion in Friedreich’s Ataxia Cells. Cell Rep 16, 1218-1227
52. Cleaver, J. E. Transcription coupled repair deficiency protects against human
mutagenesis and carcinogenesis: Personal Reflections on the 50th anniversary of
the discovery of xeroderma pigmentosum. DNA Repair (Amst) 58, 21-28 (2017).
53. Chakraborty, A. et al. Neil2-null Mice Accumulate Oxidized DNA Bases in the
Transcriptionally Active Sequences of the Genome and Are Susceptible to Innate
Inflammation. J Biol Chem 290, 24636-24648 (2015).
54. Ebrahimkhani, M. R. et al. Aag-initiated base excision repair promotes ischemia
reperfusion injury in liver, brain, and kidney. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 111,
55. Schrödinger, E. What is life?: With mind and matter and autobiographical sketches
(Cambridge University Press, 1992).
56. Vidali, S. et al. Mitochondria: The ketogenic diet-A metabolism-based therapy. Int J
Biochem Cell Biol (2015).
57. Challa, H. J. & Uppaluri, K. R. Paleolithic Diet. StatPearls, (2018).
58. Mechoulam, R. Plant cannabinoids: a neglected pharmacological treasure trove. Br
J Pharmacol 146, 913-915 (2005).